Replay every proposal against the regression set
confirmed-incidents.csv lists alerts that were investigated and confirmed as genuine incidents, each by alert id. For each proposal, check whether any of those alert ids would have been excluded. Exactly one proposal suppresses none of them and is therefore the one that can be applied — name it. Of the other two, one hides a single confirmed incident: identify which incident, by its reference. Then count how many confirmed incidents would still fire under the proposal that removes the most volume.